Download the whiskey list (PDF) (opens in a new tab)
Summer CocktailsThe cocktail list rotates with the seasonal menu.
Strawberry Lemonade Bucket
$20Tito’s, organic lemonade, strawberry, mint. Keep the bucket.
Watermelon Marg
$15Fresh watermelon juice, blanco, triple sec, fresh lime.
Samoa Espresso Tini
$17Espresso, toasted coconut rum, dark chocolate amaro, brown sugar; caramel coconut cold foam.
Rainbow Cookie Cold Brew
$15Sail Away cold brew, Frangelico, amaretto, raspberry liqueur, Baileys; served with an Uncle Joey’s rainbow cookie.
Hugo Spritz
$15St. Germain, prosecco, fresh mint, splash of club.
Cucumber Linen
$15Ketel Botanical cucumber mint, St. Germain, fresh lime, muddled cucumber, simple.
The Cherry Chick
$17Tito’s, cherry, fresh lime, splash of Sierra Mist, cherry limeade popsicle.
Buenos Dias
$1621 Seeds valencia orange tequila, triple sec, Mike’s hot honey syrup, fresh lime, tajin rim.
Blueberry Lemon Spritz
$16Le Moné lemon aperitif, blueberry fruitful, homemade blueberry syrup, prosecco.
Peach Cobbler Old Fashioned
$17Peach infused brown butter washed bourbon, caramel, brown sugar, chocolate bitters.
Zero-Proof
Paradise on the Patio
$11No booze. Pineapple, strawberry, coconut cream, lime. Add white rum $4.
Orange Creamsicle Dirty Soda
$8Orange soda, vanilla, cream.
Montauk N.A. IPA
$8Non-alcoholic IPA.
Bourbon
Maker’s Mark
$14Wild Turkey 101
$14Knob Creek
$14Great Jones
$14Four Roses
$14Woodford Reserve
$15Michter’s
$15Buffalo Trace
$15Bulleit
$15Larceny
$15Elijah Craig Small Batch
$16Widow Jane
$16Basil Hayden’s
$16Spy Trail
$18Old Forester 1897
$18Old Forester 1870
$18Old Forester 1910
$18Old Forester 1920
$19E.H. Taylor Small Batch
$20Blanton’s
$20Eagle Rare 10
$20Weller Special Reserve
$20Weller Antique 107
$21Weller 12
$23Weller Full Proof
$28Weller C.Y.P.B.
$29Weller Single Barrel
$32Rye
Templeton
$14Woodford Reserve
$15Dickel
$15Power’s Rye
$15Elijah Craig
$15Bulleit Rye
$16Johnnie Walker High Rye
$16Michter’s
$17Angel’s Envy
$18Scotch
Johnnie Walker Black
$15Speyburn
$15Monkey Shoulder
$16Dalmore 12
$16Lagavulin 8
$16Laphroaig 10
$18Glenfiddich 12
$18Macallan 12
$18Balvenie 12 Doublewood
$18Balvenie 14 Caribbean Cask
$20Irish
Powers
$14Jameson
$14Proper Twelve
$14Tullamore D.E.W.
$14Bushmills 10 Year
$18Bushmills 16 Year
$24Japanese Whisky
Suntory Whisky Toki
$15Kikori
$16Something Different
Screwball Peanut Butter
$12Ballotin Caramel Turtle
$12Redwood Empire
$14Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel
$16Crown Royal
$16Tequila & Mezcal
House Tequila
$12Don Julio Reposado
$13Don Julio Añejo
$13Casamigos Blanco
$13Casamigos Reposado
$13Casamigos Añejo
$13Casamigos Mezcal
$13Casamigos Spicy
$14Patrón
$141800
$14Tanteo
$1421 Seeds
$14Pantalones Blanco
$14Pantalones Reposado
$14Gin, Vodka & Rum
Aviation Gin
$12Ford’s Gin
$12Hendrick’s Gin
$13Zeus Gin
$13Blue Iguana Gin
$13Edinburgh Gin
$13Tito’s Vodka
$12Grey Goose Vodka
$13Ketel One Vodka
$13Bacardi Rum
$13Captain Morgan Rum
$13By the Can & GlassSeasonal cans rotate through Surfside, High Noon, Spiked Ade, Greenport Summer and Betterman Lavender Lemonade. Minuty rosé by the glass.
Current specials are posted in the dining room and on Instagram.
Shakes & Coffee
Boozy Shake
$15Shake of the Month
$12Milkshake
$10Cold Brew
$7Cappuccino
$6Iced Latte
$6Espresso
$3Pull up a stool
The bar runs the full menu, so dinner works just as well from a barstool.